EXTRA! EXTRA!
NEW SUPERHERO EMERGES FROM THE DARK!
People at the Highest Levels Being Held Responsible the World Over!
Who is this Masked Crusader?
MEET CAPTAIN ACCOUNTABILITY!
If. Only.
The abysmally low rate of accountability has been a bone of contention for me for some time now. It’s been sitting on the backburner of my mind ever since (and possibly before) the financial crisis of 2008.
[Quick aside: I’m sure a lack of accountability has been an issue since what, the dawn of humankind? However, up until the mid-2000s, I wasn’t terribly interested in history or current events. At some point, I decided a concerned and informed citizen makes a better citizen. Though I still believe that to be true, a large part of me wishes I could return to the blissful ignorance I once enjoyed.]
In some ways, we came through the “Great Recession” of the late aughts relatively unscathed. Of course, those who’d been victims of predatory lending and other risky financial practices might beg to differ, yet after a massive government bailout and a few short years, the world came out the other side and seemed to forget all about the activities of those who were responsible. While it “should be noted that the investments in the banks were fully recouped by the government, with interest”,1 very few individuals faced any kind of reckoning for their reckless behavior - except in Iceland, of all places2 - and some were, in fact, rewarded.3 I recall it was this last bit of information that especially irked me. How did so few of those responsible face repercussions?
Let’s move forward in time to 2021. I doubt it will surprise anyone that my current preoccupation with accountability is partially tied to the second impeachment trial of Donald Trump. As of mid-morning on February 13th I believed the trial would last another week or so, allowing me the opportunity to post this before the Senate voted. Unfortunately, while I was writing, the Senate voted to acquit the former President, by a vote of 57-43.4 Yes, I am disappointed, very much so, and yet this very situation proves my point directly. (Before I move on, I want you to know, the impeachment will only constitute one part of my argument. It is not the sole example I will use.)
Let’s review: on January 6, 2021, hundreds of people, possibly more than one thousand,5 stormed the United States Capitol building in an attempt to stop the certification of Joe Biden’s victory in the 2020 Presidential election. Moments before their march on the Capitol, this crowd gathered with others to listen as Donald Trump continued to make the false claim6 that the election had been stolen from him,7 the same claim he’d been making for months before the election. To say his words didn’t exacerbate the anger coursing through the audience is naive. Of course they did. I may be no fan of Donald Trump but he knows how to excite his supporters, to rile them, to make them foam. Even if he didn’t give a direct order for people to attack the Capitol, to claim he bears no blame for the ensuing chaos, is either short-sighted or blatant denial.
What I find most interesting (especially since we now know President Trump has been acquitted) is that hundreds8 have been arrested or charged with a crime for their actions on January 6th (which are completely deserved), and yet, those with positions of authority, whose words and deeds provoked these citizens, will face little to no repercussions. Donald Trump has once again walked away from an impeachment trial with nary a scratch. Those senators, representatives, and media outlets - a veritable cornucopia of people - who disseminated misinformation about election fraud are rarely even mentioned. Yet, here we are, with hundreds of their followers, who, I reiterate, are not without culpability, reaping 100% of the consequences of the unrest sowed by those above.
This trend is the most frustrating for me. Lack of accountability, especially at the highest levels, is astounding. Maybe it’s just me, but I feel like everywhere I look, some CEO, celebrity, government official, person of authority, etc is getting off easy for perpetrating an act that is either criminal, ethically questionable, or morally reprehensible.
Right here in New York state, the Attorney General found Governor Andrew Cuomo’s administration underreported the number of Covid-19 related deaths in nursing homes. Not only that, it was found that nearly 9,000 patients recovering from the coronavirus were sent to nursing homes to recover, possibly fueling the spread of the disease through that community.9 It may be too early to know for sure whom will be held responsible, if anyone, for this egregious misrepresentation of numbers, but I have a sneaking suspicion I will be left feeling wholly unsatisfied when all is said and done.
Recently, the notion of ‘cancel culture’ - “the remov[al] of support for public figures in response to their objectionable behavior or opinions”10 - has become a term used by people to express their indignation that someone is being ‘canceled’ simply for holding an unpopular opinion. This frustrates me to no end because, apparently, calling someone out on social media is unacceptable but letting those in positions of power get off easy for brazenly flouting the law is quite all right. I admit cancel culture is fraught with its own problems but let us not use the guise of cancel culture to forgo accountability.
Look, I know I’m not the only one outraged by this lack of accountability - the MeToo and BLM movements are clear in their objectives to combat this exact topic, as well as a host of others - yet is any progress being made? For every Harvey Weinstein and Bernie Madoff, there are dozens, if not more, being let off the hook for a motley of despicable acts. We cannot persist as a nation, or frankly, as a human race, if we do not find it within ourselves to not only call out criminal, ethically questionable, and morally reprehensible behavior when it occurs, but also provide consequences for those responsible. We must do it as individuals, as colleagues, as consumers, and as an electoral body. We must stop being fearful of those with power and authority. When they commit brash acts of wrongdoing, something more serious than a slap on the wrist must follow. If we continue to turn a blind eye or ‘just move on’ from these things, like many wanted to do concerning the latest impeachment trial, it will not only be our democracy we need to worry about, it will be our humanity as well.
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good [people] do nothing.11
- (often attributed to Edmund Burke)